“It seems that in every place and in all times the Jewish heart is filled with troubles. One just needs to know the right word or the touching melody, and the thick ice that forms around the Jewish heart by cold life breaks open and tears pour out.” —Jacob Dinezon, Memories and Scenes: Shtetl, Childhood, Writers, trans. Tina Lunson
Jacob Dinezon is born in Nay Zhager (New Zhager) near Kovno in Lithuania. (Many biographical entries list Dinezon’s birth year as 1856. A few suggest 1852. An 1858 record in the LitvakSIG All Lithuania Database – Part 1 shows the name Yankel Eliash Dinerzun age seven, and the Yiddish newspaper, Haynt (Today) of August 1919 reports that Dinezon was 68 years old when he died, which makes the year of his birth 1851—the year we use here.)
Young Jacob grows up in a comfortable Jewish household with a doting mother, Pessie, and a father, Benjamin, who is often away on business. He has two older sisters, one younger sister, and a brother who dies in early childhood.
At four years old, Dinezon is enrolled in cheder to begin his Jewish education learning Torah. A small, bright, gifted student, he suffers through a series of old-fashioned cheder teachers who are quick to use corporal punishment on their young charges. Later, Dinezon wrote about one teacher in his “Recollections”: “He would beat without a reason and chopped our backs like cabbages. Even in the evening when he dismissed us, he would distribute advance payment for the next day. The advance was particularly large on Fridays, so we would remember him until after the Sabbath.”
“I began to write when I was barely ten years old. Why I wrote I don’t exactly know. But for as long as I can remember, everything which would move another to cry out, to speak, to complain, or even to laugh, moved me to take the pen in hand and write . . . until my awakening heart spent itself and became peaceful.” —Jacob Dinezon, “Jacob Dinezon’s Letters” with commentary by S. Niger, Di Tsukunft (The Future), trans. Jane Peppler (NY: 1929), pp. 620-621
Dinezon enters the yeshiva at age twelve.
Shortly thereafter, his father dies, and he is sent to live with an uncle in the Russian city of Mohilev (Mogilev) on the Dnieper River.
Dinezon is enrolled in a prestigious Jewish school that embraces the spirit of the Haskalah (Jewish Enlightenment). He learns Russian, German, mathematics, world history, and science.
At sixteen, Dinezon lives and studies in the home of Simcha Zuckerman, a pious man of newly acquired wealth, in the city of Mir. Here Dinezon helps Zuckerman build a library of religious books and Enlightenment literature published in Hebrew. While translating a weekly Hebrew newspaper for Zuckerman’s family, Dinezon comes to realize the value of Yiddish as a way of communicating Enlightenment ideas to Jews who are not literate in Hebrew.
Dinezon enters the employ of a wealthy and prominent family in Mohilev named Horowitz. Starting as a Hebrew tutor, he is soon promoted to bookkeeper and then to manager of the family business.
He becomes a trusted member of the Horowitz household, and Bodana Horowitz, the family matriarch, becomes a second mother to him.
The Horowitz home is a gathering place for disaffected young people struggling to break away from the restrictive customs of traditional Jewish religious life, including an insular worldview, rigid gender roles, and arranged marriages. Here Dinezon finds poignant and emotional material for his future novels.
During this period, according to the literary historian S. L. Tsitron, Dinezon falls in love with the Horowitzes’s only daughter, whom he is tutoring. He escorts her on travels to foreign lands to study music, yet is never able to reveal his true feelings.
The relationship ends sadly when, at the request of the family, Dinezon must travel to Vilna to make arrangements for the girl’s marriage to another man.
Dinezon begins publishing articles in Hebrew newspapers and publishes scholarly brochures on scientific subjects, including “Thunder and Lightning” and “Rain and Snow.”
Heading to Vilna with an introduction from Bodana Horowitz to her sister Devorah Romm, head of the famed Widow and Brothers Romm publishing company, Dinezon meets the renowned Yiddish writer Isaac Meyer Dik, who assists him with the sale of his first novel, Beoven avos (For the Sins of the Fathers) for twenty-three rubles. Due to censorship, the manuscript is never published and ultimately lost.
To replace the censored book, the Widow and Brothers Romm publishes Dinezon’s Ha-ne’ehavim veha-ne’imim, oder, Der shvartser yungermantshik (The Beloved and Pleasing, or, The Dark Young Man).
This same year Dinezon moves to Moscow, where he works at a tea company for one of his relatives. While there he learns that The Dark Young Man has been published. The novel quickly becomes a great sensation, with the first ten thousand copies selling out quickly and several reprints to follow. About this first book, it is said that for many years the names of the characters were household words as though people actually knew them.
“There was hardly a Jewish home where all the members of the family—old and young, male and female—had not read the novel and not shed hot tears of sympathy for the sufferings of the unfortunate Yosef, Rukhame, and Roza; while the name of the evil young man, Meyshe Shneyur, became the byword for hypocrisy, cruelty, and murder.” —Nachman Mayzel, “A Few Words About This Edition,” in The Beloved and Pleasing, or the Dark Young Man, trans. Tina Lunson (New York: S. Sreberk, 1928)
While in Moscow, Dinezon learns that his literary hero, the Hebrew writer Sholem Abramovitsh, is using the pen name Mendele Mocher Sforim (Mendele the Book Seller) for the works he is writing in Yiddish. When Dinezon asks why Abramovitsh would use a pseudonym, the informant replies, “Would you wear your Sabbath coat to the shop on weekdays?”
Despite the great success of The Dark Young Man with the general public, Dinezon is disappointed by the negative critical response the novel receives from the Enlightenment press because it is written in Yiddish and not Hebrew. At the time, Yiddish was considered a lowly language only worthy of the home, street, and marketplace. Hebrew was the elevated language of the religious scholar and enlightened intellectual. Dinezon was devastated by the criticism leveled at him for writing in the disdained “zhargon” (jargon).
Dinezon is also distressed by the sudden appearance of opportunistic Yiddish writers and their shamefully imitative works. In response, although he continues to write, he ceases to publish another Yiddish novel for thirteen years.
“I felt guilty for the whole flood of vapid and dismal novels drowning the Jewish reader. I couldn’t stop writing, but it didn’t cost me effort or mental strain not to publish the finished works.” —Jacob Dinezon, “Jacob Dinezon’s Letters” with commentary by S. Niger, Di Tsukunft (The Future), trans. Jane Peppler (NY: 1929), pp. 620-621
The assassination of Tsar Alexander II in 1881 and the accession of Alexander III leads to pogroms throughout the Russian Empire and the imposition of the May Laws, which intensify restrictions on Jews living in the Pale of Settlement. Jews are prohibited from residing outside of towns and boroughs, owning or managing real estate property or leasing land, and operating their businesses on Sundays or other Christian holidays. These edicts essentially dash any hope that Jewish writers will be permitted to engage in Russian cultural pursuits under the new tsar.
Dinezon moves to Warsaw to be closer to his older sister and her family. His small attic apartment at Dzielna No. 15 becomes a focal point for the city’s Jewish literary circle, and Dinezon becomes a mentor and advisor to fledgling Yiddish writers.
While visiting Kiev, Dinezon is arrested and jailed for several hours until his identity is verified and papers have been approved.
This same year, Sholem Aleichem comes to Dinezon’s small apartment to discuss his plan to publish a Jewish literary anthology. Also present are David Frishman and Samuel Tsitron. Sholem Aleichem’s goal, he says, is to elevate Yiddish literature.
Dinezon contributes advice and a short story, “Go Eat Kreplach,” to Sholem Aleichem’s new venture. Also included in the first volume is a long poem by I. L. Peretz entitled “Monish.” Peretz, whose law practice had collapsed following his disbarment by the Tsarist authorities, was just beginning to write seriously in Yiddish. Although Sholem Aleichem publishes the poem, he makes critical edits without first informing Peretz. This leads to a feud that lasts for many years.
When Dinezon reads “Monish” in Sholem Aleichem’s Di yidishe folks-bibliotek (The Jewish People’s Library), he corresponds with Peretz to express his enthusiasm for Peretz’s writing.
Peretz moves to Warsaw, where he finally meets Dinezon. They become inseparable friends.
Perhaps through Peretz’s encouragement, Dinezon begins to publish again. His book Even negef, oder, a shteyn in veg (Stumbling Block, or, A Stone in the Road) is published in Vilna.
Dinezon pays for the publication of Peretz’s first book of Yiddish stories, Bekante bilder (Familiar Pictures), a collection of three short stories, “The Messenger,” “What Is Soul?” and “The Mad Talmudist.”
“Mr. Peretz writes not to flatter the coarse taste of the lower class of reader; rather, he wants to refine and improve him. So we are not being excessive in inviting the honorable readers—who are not yet accustomed to it—into a small Yiddish booklet to find something good in it.” —Jacob Dinezon, Bakante bilder (Familiar Scenes) by Leon Peretz, ed. Y. Dinezon, trans. Tina Lunson (Warsaw: Boymriter, 1890)
Dinezon intends Bakante bilder to be the first in a series of books in a “penny library” that will bring Jewish readers stories of substance in Yiddish. No additional books are published.
This same year Sholem Aleichem must cease publication of Di yidishe folks-bibliotek after suffering major losses in a Russian stock market crash.
In partnership, Dinezon and Peretz begin publishing their own literary anthology, Di yidishe bibliotek (The Jewish Library), which runs until 1894. The name infuriates Sholem Aleichem.
Dinezon’s book, Hershele, is published as a supplement in The Jewish Library.
With anti-Semitism growing in Russia and Russian-controlled lands and increasing deportments of Jews to the Pale of Settlement, Dinezon and Peretz make plans to settle in Argentina where thousands of Eastern European Jews are emigrating. Their intention is to start a daily Jewish newspaper, but their plans never materialize.
Dinezon moves to Kiev and becomes engaged in the city’s literary community. Four years later, in 1896, he returns to Warsaw, where he lives with his older sister Fayja Kac and her family for the remaining years of his life.
Dinezon assists Peretz and David Pinski with the publishing of Yontef bletlekh (Holiday Pages) as a creative way of getting around the Tsarist ban on Jewish newspapers. Between 1894 and 1896, they publish seventeen issues.
Dinezon writes an angry article that is critical of the German historian and biblical scholar Henrich Graetz for refusing to allow his monumental history of the Jews to be translated into Yiddish. Dinezon’s response is a powerful defense of Russian Jewry and the Yiddish language. Graetz ultimately acquiesces, and Dinezon goes on to translate three parts of the work, although a conflict with the publisher compels Dinezon to remove his name from the finished work.
In February, his short story “Foolishness: The Community Goat” is published in two installments in Der yud. He begins the tale about blind obedience to tradition with comments about the ongoing antisemitic Dreyfus Affair in France.
Dinezon’s book Yosele is published in Warsaw. The emotional novel about a poorly treated schoolboy has a profound effect on transforming traditional Jewish education at the turn of the 20th century.
“Dinezon immortalized the abandoned, neglected orphaned child in his Yosele. That novel, snatched up eagerly as a critique of the old-fashioned cheder, seemed to all preachers of modern Jewish education as a true picture of the class-division that had been built up in Jewish life in the nineteenth century, and as an urging for fundamental educational reform in order to place it on a foundation of fairness and goodness.” —Introduction by Samuel Rozshanski, in Yosele. The Crisis: Novels and Studies on the Jewish Literature by Jacob Dinezon, trans. Jane Peppler (Buenos-Ayres: Yosef Lifshits-fond beim kultur-kongres in Argentina, 1959)
Peretz is arrested while speaking at a Jewish labor workers’ meeting and is imprisoned for three months in the Tenth Pavilion of the Warsaw Citadel. When Peretz is released, he is ill and seriously malnourished.
Dinezon spearheads a three-day celebration in Warsaw to celebrate I. L. Peretz’s fiftieth birthday and twenty-fifth year as a writer. To celebrate the event, Dinezon collects, edits, and publishes a volume of Peretz’s collected works.
During the celebration, a delegation from the Arbeter Bund (The Jewish Workers Union) presents Peretz with a written proclamation and gift: a book of Peretz’s stories that Jewish political prisoners had used to send secret messages to each other in the Warsaw Citadel. Peretz keeps the book as a prized possession, but Dinezon burns the proclamation to destroy any evidence of Peretz’s association with the outlawed Jewish workers’ party.
Peretz suffers a near-fatal heart attack and is sent to the resort town of Marienbad, Germany, to recuperate.
In December, the Yudishe folks tsaytung (Jewish People’s Newspaper) celebrates Dinezon’s 25th year as a writer with a photograph and three-part Jubilee retrospective by Dr. K. D. Hurvitz. The literary critic Bal-Makhshoves (Isidor Eliashev) also commemorates the event in an essay published the following May in Der fraynd (The Friend).
Dinezon continues to provide stories to Yiddish newspapers. His novella, Alter, appears in installments in Der fraynd (The Friend). News of the Kishinev pogrom and massacre horrifies Russian Jewry and reverberates around the world.
As the Russo-Japanese war rages in Asia, Dinezon has one of his most prolific years as an author. Appearing in the pages of Der fraynd alongside Sholem Aleichem, I. L. Peretz, Mendele Mocher Sforim, and S. An-ski, Dinezon contributes short stories, holiday tales, non-fiction, and two novellas, Falik in zayn hoyz (Falik and His House) and Der krizis (The Crisis: A Story of the Lives of Merchants).
On July 3, Theodor Herzl, the founder of modern Zionism, dies in Vienna. Ten days later, Dinezon’s tribute to Herzl appears on the front page of Der fraynd.
The Tsarist government lifts the ban against Yiddish theater. Peretz begins writing plays, and Dinezon works to bring Yiddish theater to Warsaw.
In January 1905, a failed Russian Revolution brings Cossacks and Russian soldiers to the city as the Tsar attempts to suppress the rebellion.
Dinezon is invited to America by Johan Paley, the editor of the New York Yiddish newspaper, the Jewish Daily News. Dinezon declines the offer while Warsaw’s Jews continue to suffer under Russian oppression in the aftermath of the failed Revolution.
“Let me assure you that I fully appreciate your offer, but to make use of your steamer ship ticket is quite out of the question. My place is here with my people, come what may.” —Jacob Dinezon, “Evening Star,” Chronicling America, August 19, 1906, p. 5 (U.S. Library of Congress)
Peretz and Dinezon sign an invitation urging participation in the “Conference for the Yiddish Language” to be held in Czernowitz, Austria. Although Dinezon does not attend, Peretz addresses the conference, which seeks to elevate Yiddish to a modern, national language for the Jewish people.
In celebration of Sholem Aleichem’s 50th birthday and 25th Writer’s Jubilee, Dinezon organizes an effort to buy back Sholem Aleichem’s copyrights from the original publishers. The return of these copyrights allows Sholem Aleichem to earn much-needed income from the republication of his stories. Sholem Aleichem replies with a letter of thanks to “Uncle Dinezon.”
The First World War begins. Dinezon again partners with Peretz to help found the Home for Jewish Children, an orphanage to care for the many displaced children arriving in Warsaw from the Russian-German war zone.
In Dinezon’s Warsaw apartment, Sholem Aleichem and Peretz finally end their feud and make plans to conduct a lecture tour in America.
The Germans enter Warsaw during the month of October.
An-ski stays with Peretz during November and December. An-ski describes the situation in Warsaw in his “Memories of Peretz and Dinezon.”
On April 3rd, during Passover, Peretz dies of a heart attack in his Warsaw apartment. Dinezon sits as a shomer (watchman) until his friend’s body is removed and transported to the cemetery. One hundred thousand mourners turn out for Peretz’s funeral.
“Quiet and simple was the mourning chamber in which rested the deceased body of I. L. Peretz. . . . The endless stream of visitors made it impossible for one to linger more than just a moment. The people kept changing, but the stream of quiet tears never ceased. The well-known writer, Dinezon, the dearest friend of the deceased, never for a moment left the dead body.” —A. A. Roback, I. L. Peretz: Psychologist of Literature (Cambridge, MA: Sci-Art Publishers, 1935)
With Peretz gone, a grief-stricken Jacob Dinezon turns his attention and support to Poland’s Yiddish secular schools’ movement.
On May 13th, Sholem Aleichem dies in America. Over one hundred and fifty thousand mourners line the streets of New York City for his funeral.
In the same year as the Russian Revolution, Dinezon’s friend Sholem Abramovitsh dies in Odessa.
On Friday evening, August 29, surrounded by family and friends, Jacob Dinezon dies in his sister’s Warsaw apartment at Karmelica 29. Because it is the beginning of Sabbath and newspapers will not appear again until Sunday morning, news of Dinezon’s death is spread by word of mouth.
In a show of solidarity, Jewish mourners from all walks of life and political ideologies come out in the tens of thousands to express their grief on the day of his funeral, August 31.
His final wish is fulfilled when he is buried beside his friend I. L. Peretz in the Okopowa Street Jewish Cemetery.
“Even if Dinezohn had made no noteworthy contribution to Yiddish letters, his services in behalf of suffering humanity would have endeared him to the Jewish people. The fame of his work for the war orphans of Poland has gone far. Dinezohn’s schools, Dinezohn’s home for children, Dinezohn’s little orphan wards come to mind whenever his name is mentioned. He will long be remembered as a rare and great soul.” —The Sentinel, Chicago, Illinois, September 12, 1919, No. 11, p. 8
S. An-ski dies on November 8 and is also buried beside Peretz and Dinezon in Warsaw’s Jewish Cemetery.
On May 25, a grand monument by sculptor Abraham Ostrzega is unveiled in the Okopowa Street Jewish Cemetery to commemorate the tenth anniversary of I. L. Peretz’s death. Jews call it Ohel Peretz (Peretz’s Tomb). Poles call it the Mauzoleum Trzech Pisarzy (Mausoleum of the Three Writers) because Jacob Dinezon and S. An-ski also lie beneath its ornate granite edifice.
Nearly the entire population of Jewish Warsaw is murdered or deported by the Nazis during the Second World War. Neighborhoods within the Warsaw Ghetto are reduced to rubble or burned to the ground. Miraculously, the Jewish Cemetery remains mostly unscathed.
A memorial event is held on August 31 in the Jewish Cemetery of Warsaw to commemorate the 100th anniversary of Jacob Dinezon’s death. Organized by the Jewish Historical Institute as part of the Singer’s Warsaw Cultural Festival, barely a dozen participants show up for the service. Only three are Jewish.
While at the very same time in America, a Yiddish version of Fiddler on the Roof, based on Sholem Aleichem’s “Tevye the Dairy Man” stories plays to sold out crowds in New York City.
Jacob Dinezon is the optimist of our Yiddish literature. For him, evil is just a matter of chance, and he is confident that good will always triumph over the unfortunate accidents of life. The person who looks at God’s little world through the eyes of a faithful, devoted mother could not feel otherwise; he lives with a deep belief that within a shadow, one can find a thousand bright colors. —Bal-Makhshoves (“Man of Thoughts”), “Jacob Dinezon,” The Gathered Writings of Bal-Makhshoves, trans. Jane Peppler, (Washington, D.C.: S. Shreberk, 1910), vol. 1, p. 113–120